Meet our Team

You can rely on our team of full-time professionals who are specially trained and appropriately certified to represent your best interests. We are a family of companies that works together for you.

Fort Wayne

Tim McCulloch's Profile Image

Tim McCulloch

President

Member IAA, NAA, REALTOR®, USPAP

Partner, Real Estate and Personal Property Auctioneer, Appraiser, Real Estate Broker

Tim McCulloch has been in the auction business for over 25 years, and started his own company in 1997. Since then, he has expanded his services to include senior relocations, appraisals, auctioning real estate and personal property, traditional real estate sales and international online auctions.

Tim enjoys meeting many types of people, and being able to educate and find solutions for his clients. Helping them make financial gains is the icing on the cake for him. He also gets satisfaction from helping charitable organizations in their fundraising efforts.

When he’s not working, Tim likes spending time with his two young sons, watching sports and participating in tennis and yoga.

Penny Gentile's Profile Image

Penny Gentile

Business Manager

Penny Gentile joined the company in July 2016 to manage and oversee the day-to-day operations of the business. Her business background in management and human resources in the legal field aligns with the company’s overall strategy and goals.

After college, Penny spent several years in the San Francisco bay area working as a legal administrator. She returned to her hometown of Fort Wayne where she enjoys marriage, running and golf. 

David Meyers's Profile Image

David Meyers

Real Estate Agent/Auctioneer

Member IAA, NAA, USPAP

Real Estate and Personal Property Auctioneer, Appraiser, Real Estate Broker (IN, MI)

David joined the company in 2008 as sales manager for the lakes regions of Indiana and Michigan. Since that time, we have been able to help many families auction their waterfront homes and personal belongings, and we have David to thank for the growth of our business in that area.

David has a keen interest in the unique homes and belongings he encounters in his work. Having spent his childhood on the lake, this is where he feels most at home. He also likes helping people get value from their belongings when the time comes to downsize.

When he’s not working, David loves working on home projects and landscaping. He and his wife, Elizabeth, have 4 children and are looking forward to living on Lake Michigan someday.

Brian Tilley's Profile Image

Brian Tilley

Senior Relocation Manager

Brian started with Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers in 2001. He was hired to develop the moving division of the company, which has become one of the most respected Senior Relocation companies in the region.

Over the years he has formed many great relationships, which are a favorite aspect of his job. The retirement centers that recommend us know they can count on nothing but the best in the way their clients and their belongings will be treated.

When he’s not making seniors happy, Brian spends a lot of his time watching or playing sports.

Kevin Sunderland's Profile Image

Kevin Sunderland

Creative Director/Designer

University of Saint Francis graduate

Kevin joined our company in 2011, using his creative skills to give every property we auction maximum visibility. He photographs auction properties and items, writes them up for web and print materials, and guides the purchase of advertising to target the most appropriate audiences.

Kevin loves designing and creating new ways to get the word out about our clients’ properties. We are known for our effective marketing, and Kevin is a big reason why.

When he’s not being a creative mad man at work, he’s spending time with his beautiful wife and two daughters. In addition to being a family man, Kevin is an avid golfer and sports nut. He also continues to pursue his love of doing art when he has the time.

Lisa McCulloch's Profile Image

Lisa McCulloch

Consignment Assistant/Designer

Lisa has been with us since 2009, and has become very knowledgable and skilled in the consignment end of our business. She loves the exposure to the treasures, antiques and collections that clients bring to us, as well as photographing and doing the research about them before putting them online.

Lisa is the mother of 3 boys, and enjoys spending time with her family, staying fit and scrapbooking.

Marilyn Brown's Profile Image

Marilyn Brown

Office Assistant / Closing Coordinator

Marilyn Brown joined the company in August of 2016 as our Office Assistant. In this role, she helps coordinate and track the many important activities that must happen before and after an auction to ensure successful outcomes for our clients.

Prior to joining Scheerer McCulloch, Marilyn managed a small legal office that specialized in estate planning and administration. She also spent 15 years working in a large law firm that handled real estate, foreclosures and litigation.

Outside of work, Marilyn enjoys being with her family, taking walks with her lab and spending time with her grandson. She and her husband share hobbies that include refurbishing furniture and creating mason jar lighting.
 

Carol Dellinger's Profile Image

Carol Dellinger

Auction Administration Support

REALTOR®, National Association of Realtors, e-PRO®

Carol Dellinger started with us late in 2015. Prior to that she had worked with Tim McCulloch on an auction, and really enjoyed the process. She provides part-time cashier and clerking support, and loves the exposure to the people and treasures she encounters at each auction.

Carol has three children, two grandkids and two dogs. In addition to time spent with her family, she says she is a fanatic reader!

Stacy Hirschy's Profile Image

Stacy Hirschy

Auctioneer/Auction Assistant

Member IAA, 1981 Reppert Auction School graduate

Stacy is licensed to lead auctions in Indiana, Ohio and Florida and has been working with Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers since 2008. He auctions real estate, personal property and cars, and enjoys the diversity of his work, knowing that no two days are exactly alike.

In his spare time, Stacy likes spending time on the Barbee Chain of lakes with his family, and attending church at The Chapel.

Justin Shirley's Profile Image

Justin Shirley

Moving and Auction Support

Justin Shirley joined us in August 2014 to provide packing, moving and auction set-up support. He now calls himself the Swiss Army Knife of the company, being willing and able to jump in and do whatever needs to be done on any given day in preparation and follow-up to our auctions.

What Justin enjoys about his job is the fact that even though every auction is different, the process is nearly the same. This gives him confidence because he knows what needs to be done, but he also enjoys the variety and creativity of his work.

Justin is married and is the proud new father of a son born in June 2016. In his free time he likes to spend time with his family or watch sports. 

Tony Feipel's Profile Image

Tony Feipel

Moving and Auction Support

Tony Feipel joined us in April 2015. He provides packing and moving support, as well as helping to set up auctions. He likes the physical aspect of the job, which keeps him in shape. He also enjoys seeing the interesting pieces that are in the various auctions, including what they sell for.

Tony stays active outside of work, too, as a league volleyball player. 

Huntington

Tim Scheerer's Profile Image

Tim Scheerer

Vice-President

Member IAA,

Partner, Auctioneer, Personal Property Appraiser

Tim became a partner in the company in 2008, when Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers was formed. He and his wife, Chris, have been in the auction business for over 25 years, and manage our Huntington office. His true passion in the auction business is selling farm land and equipment, and guns. He enjoys the unique items our clients sell through the auction process, and likes meeting new people, as well as seeing our regular auction attendees.

Tim loves spending time with his family and grandchildren. In his own time, he likes shooting and gun collecting.

Chris Scheerer's Profile Image

Chris Scheerer

Secretary/Clerk

Partner, Personal property appraiser

Chris became a partner in the company in 2008, when Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers was formed. She and her husband, Tim, have been in the auction business for over 25 years, and manage our Huntington office. She loves helping clients from start to finish with smooth transitions. She is always happy to see our auction customers, many of whom she considers friends.

Chris loves reading and home remodeling, but nothing comes close to the joy she gets from spending time with her family. She has been married to Tim Scheerer for 30 years, and they have 4 sons, 2 daughters-in-law and 7 beautiful grandchildren.

Brent Broderick's Profile Image

Brent Broderick

Auctioneer/Auction Assistant

Brent Broderick was recruited to work with us in March 2016. He received his auctioneer’s license in 2004, and has worked independently, mostly in real estate, personal property and estate sales.

Brent has loved auctions since he was a kid, and continues to nurture that love in his work with us.

Brent has two grown children - a son and a daughter. He lives in Bluffton, where he pursues real estate investing and fixing up homes. He enjoys riding his Harley Davidson motorcycle and is a huge football fan. 

Richard Bennett's Profile Image

Richard Bennett

Auction Setup Manager

Richard retired in 2002 from Kmart Distribution Center after 27 years with the company. That same year he began working with Tim and Chris Scheerer to help set up their auctions. When Scheerer Mcculloch formed in 2008, he was invited to come along. Richard loves working with the staff because of the way they all work together and make such a great team. 

In his spare time, Richard enjoys gardening and traveling, but most of all spending time with his two kids and two grandsons. He and his wife are thrilled that grandtwins will be arriving later this year. 

Chuck Miller's Profile Image

Chuck Miller

Auction Set-up Assistant

Chuck Miller joined us in June 2014 to provide full-time auction set-up support. We’re glad to have his dependable nature and helpful skills at nearly every auction we do.

Chuck loves going to the various locations, learning new things and having so much variety in his day-to-day work experience.

When he’s not at work, you’ll probably find Chuck outdoors, camping, fishing or canoeing.

Neal Synder's Profile Image

Neal Synder

Auctioneer/Auction Assistant

Member IAA

Neal has been working with Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers since 2012. He enjoys meeting new people and setting up and selling all the different merchandise at our auctions. He also loves having the opportunity to help people through benefit auctions in Fort Wayne, Huntington and Andrews, Indiana.

Neal lives in Andrews and enjoys spending time there with his son, Braydon.

Peggy Wells's Profile Image

Peggy Wells

Real Estate Broker/Clerk & Cashier

Member IAR, NAR, REALTOR®

Peggy joined the company in 2008 when we bought Larry F. Wells & Associates from her and her husband. She has been a real estate professional for 35 years, and is a member of the local, state and national Realtor Associations. She served as past president of the Huntington Association of Realtors and is a participating member of numerous other Huntington organizations.

In addition to listing, clerking and cashiering at our auctions, Peggy continues to list and sell real estate from Scheerer McCulloch’s Huntington office.

Peggy enjoys working with the public and meeting new people. She relaxes by traveling, gardening, walking, baking, and especially by spending time with her family, grandchildren and friends.

Indianapolis

Allen Donnelly's Profile Image

Allen Donnelly

Auction and Senior Relocation Specialist, Indianapolis and Southern Indiana region

Auctioneer, Licensed Residential Appraiser, REALTOR®, Member IAA

Allen has been associated with Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers since 2011, and has helped with many residential appraisals in Northern Indiana.  Allen is recognized for his timely manner and flexibility in meeting the customer’s appraisal needs.  He has been involved in the real estate field for over 20 years in various roles, with over 15 years as a licensed real estate appraiser.

Allen is a graduate of Indiana University, and is married with three grown children. In addition to IU basketball, Allen enjoys playing handball with his friends.  He has been active in his community over the years and has served on various boards and committees.  He has also been active in youth sports, including coaching soccer and basketball.

South Bend

Mike Anderson's Profile Image

Mike Anderson

Auction Support and Construction Services

Mike Anderson joined the company in 2009, working open houses, providing pre-auction and auction day support, and helping with fundraisers. His nearly 20 years experience in the restoration business has been a big asset to us, with properties that need work prior to being ready to auction.

Mike finds his work with Scheerer McCulloch to be a rewarding and educational experience.

Mike attended the Fort Wayne Art Institute (IPFW) before marrying his high school sweetheart on February 14, 1986 and relocating to Goshen. He and his wife have two grown sons, and spend their free time cooking, gardening, fishing and enjoying the beaches of Lake Michigan.