Family-Owned and operated company serving Indianapolis and Fort Wayne areas. Licensed in Indiana, Ohio and Michigan

Meet Our Team

Our Services

We have a large staff as well as our own resources such as a large secured building, multiple moving trucks, dumpsters, and more. Our experienced team focuses on tight schedules and timelines to accomplish projects. Our reputation in the area and our list of services sets us apart. See how our team can help meet your needs.

Our Fort Wayne Team

Tim McCulloch

Tim McCulloch

President

Tim has been in the auction business for over 40 years. After starting his own company in 1997, Tim expanded his service offerings to include senior relocations, appraisals, auctioning real estate and personal property, traditional real estate sales, and international online auctions. He enjoys getting to know people and finding the right solutions for his clients. Helping them achieve financial gains is one of the highlights of his work. When he’s not working, Tim enjoys assisting charitable organizations with their fundraising efforts, spending time with his sons, and watching and participating in various sports. Tim is a Member IAA, NAA REALTORâ and serves Scheerer McCulloch in the capacity of Partner, Real Estate and Personal Property Auctioneer, Appraiser, and Real Estate Broker.

Phil Bundy

Phil Bundy

Chief Operating Officer | Director

Phil comes to Scheerer McCulloch with over 30 years of experience in the banking industry. For most of those years, he worked in the commercial lending and private client divisions for local and regional banks and a credit union. In addition to his banking career, Phil co-owned and assisted with the management of a quality assurance business that served a major computer company and numerous manufacturers, with locations in Round Rock, TX, and Nashville, TN. Phil enjoys serving his community and has served on boards and volunteered with several non-profits and his local Catholic church. When he’s not working, Phil enjoys spending time with his wife of 29 years and their six children.

Lisa McCulloch

Lisa McCulloch

Consignment Director

Lisa joined Scheerer McCulloch in 2009 and has enjoyed honing her skills in the consignment side of our business. She loves working with and researching the treasures, antiques, and collectibles that clients bring to us and utilizes her photography skills to carefully photograph each item before listing them online. In her free time, Lisa enjoys spending time with her three sons, staying fit, and scrapbooking.

Justin Shirley

Justin Shirley

Moving and Auction Support

Justin joined Scheerer McCulloch in 2014 and is known as our “Swiss Army Knife.” He’s willing and able to jump in and do whatever needs to be done on any given day to prepare for and follow-up on our auctions. Justin enjoys the fact that, while every auction is unique, the process is the same. This allows him to create efficient processes and operate confidently to help clients achieve their goals. When he’s not working, Justin likes to spend time with his wife and young son, preferably watching sports.

Stacy Hirschy

Stacy Hirschy

Auctioneer/Auction Assistant

Stacy is licensed to lead auctions in Indiana, Ohio, and Florida and holds 5 licenses, overall. He has been working with Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers since 2009 and auctions real estate, personal property, and cars. He enjoys auctioneering because of the diversity of his work – no two days are exactly alike. In his spare time, Stacy likes spending time on the Barbee chain of lakes with his family and attending church at the Chapel in Fort Wayne. Stacy is a Member of the IAA and has been a Licensed Auctioneer since 1982.

Brent Broderick

Brent Broderick

Auctioneer/Auction Assistant

Brent began working with Scheerer McCulloch in 2016. He received his auctioneer’s license in 2004 and has worked independently ever since, mostly in real estate, personal property, and estate sales. Brent has loved auctions since he was a kid and continues to nurture that love in his work with us. Brent has two grown children – a son and a daughter. He lives in Bluffton, where he pursues real estate investing and fixing up homes. He enjoys riding his Harley Davidson motorcycle and is a huge football fan.

Mica Bundy

Mica Bundy

Personal Property Auction Task Coordinator

Mica has over nine years of experience working with the public in a customer service capacity. Born and raised in Michigan, Mica is a mom to two young girls who keep her busy at home. In her free time, she loves to bake and play her ukulele.

Sean Veith

Sean Veith

Customer Relations Specialist

Sean joined our team in April 2023. He brings over a decade of experience in customer relations and is often the first person to greet visitors at The Lantern. When he’s not helping customers or answering the phones, Sean enjoys meeting with good friends for good conversations.

Michael Polomchak

Michael Polomchak

Moving Operations Manager

Michael oversees Scheerer McCulloch’s delivery of cost-effective, high-quality moving and packing, relocation, and downsizing services. He leads a highly competent team of professionals who provide white glove service as they move, pack, disassemble, and reassemble your furniture and belongings. This team’s main goal is to execute your relocation in a timely and stress-free manner.

Nick Shearer

Nick Shearer

Senior Relocation Specialist

Nick is a valuable member of Scheerer McCulloch’s Senior Relocation team who goes a long way to ensure your move-in or out is stress-free. Nick is a professional, dedicated member of our team and is key to executing your move and exceeding your expectations.

Brad Shearer

Senior Relocation Specialist

Nadine Sims

Client Service Specialist
Tracy Minnick

Tracy Minnick

Director of Consignment Inventory - Lantern

Since joining Scheerer McCulloch in 2022, Tracy has become an integral part of the team. Tracy thrives on the thrill of the treasure hunt. She brings energy and enthusiasm to every project, diving right in to uncover hidden gems. Her strong organizational skills and commitment to efficiency ensures every task is handled with precision and care. Tracy’s favorite era is Mid-Century Modern. When she’s not at work, you can find Tracy enjoying the great outdoors and lake time.

Corene Painter

Corene Painter

Consignment & Research Specialist/Cataloger

Corene joined the Scheerer McCulloch catalog team in April 2022. She has 20+ years of experience in collectibles, auctions, and the buying and selling of antiques and vintage items. Personally, she collects Victorian cabinet cards, tin types & albums; vintage fairy lights and lamps (Fenton, Indiana Glass, and Viking); vintage computers and video games; decanters, oddities, and art! Her hobbies include camping, backpacking, rehabbing farmland she recently purchased to meadows and spending time with her husband and dogs.

Britney Vargas

Britney Vargas

Cataloger

Britney has nine years of experience in customer service and three years of experience in retail management. She works part-time with Scheerer McCulloch and enjoys spending her free time with her baby boy, honing her photography skills, and making others laugh with quirky comedy quotes and dramatic expressions. According to Britney, “Life is like a camera. Focus on what’s important, capture the good times, develop from the negatives, and if things don’t work out, take another shot.”

Our Indianapolis Team

Tim Maniscalo

Tim Maniscalo

Senior Vice President

Tim joined Scheerer McCulloch in April 2022 as Senior Vice President, focusing on developing the central Indiana market. Prior to his current position, Tim served for eight years as President & CEO of the Better Business Bureau Serving Central Indiana and had a 30-year career with Dow AgroSciences. Tim enjoys walking and reading history books. He lives in Zionville with his wife, Amy, and their daughter, Sarah.

Founder Tribute

Tim Scheerer

In Memory of Tim Scheerer

Late Vice President

Tim and his wife, Chris, became partners in the company in 2008, when Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers was formed. He and Chris were in the auction business for over 25 years and managed our Huntington office together. His true passion in the auction business was selling farmland and farm equipment and guns. He enjoyed the unique items our clients sold through the auction process and loved meeting new people. When he wasn’t working, Tim loved spending time with his family and grandchildren or shooting and gun collecting. Tim is missed greatly.

Sign up for Text notifications

By providing your phone number, you agree to receive text messages from Scheerer McCulloch Auctioneers, Inc. at this number: +1 (260) 202-1016.

Reply STOP to cancel notifications and START to resume. Standard message and data rates may apply.

Sign up for Email Notifications

Enter your Email Address below to receive Email notifications.